🎧 Episode 20: Insulin Resistance & Thyroid Health: Fertility Guide | Dr. Chhaya Makhija

🎥 Watch the Video Podcast
Watch the video version for a more dynamic, in-depth experience.

🎧 Listen to the Audio Podcast

Prefer to listen while on the go? Tune in to the audio version for easy access during your commute, workout, or daily routine.

Introduction

How does metabolic health affect your ability to conceive? In this episode of The WOVA Circle Podcast, we sit down with Dr. Chhaya Makhija — triple-board certified endocrinologist and lifestyle medicine specialist with nearly 20 years of experience caring for patients joins The WOVA Circle to break down the surprising connection between insulin resistance, thyroid health, and fertility — and shares practical, evidence-based steps you can take today.

What You'll Learn in This Episode

  • What metabolic health means and why it's essential for fertility — for both men and women

  • How insulin resistance works and why you can have it even with "normal" blood sugar

  • Which tests to request beyond A1C, including HOMA-IR for early detection

  • How insulin resistance disrupts ovulation by increasing androgen production

  • Why certain ethnicities, especially South Asians, are at higher risk even at lower body weights

  • Simple, cost-free swaps to reduce endocrine-disrupting chemicals from everyday plastics

  • Lifestyle medicine fundamentals: plant-forward eating, movement, breathwork, and sleep

  • When GLP-1 medications are appropriate and who they're not for

  • Thyroid health basics: TSH vs. T4 vs. TPO antibodies, and miscarriage risk

  • The two-way connection between hypothyroidism and insulin resistance

⏱ Listen time: 51 minutes 🎧 Format: Video & Audio 📍 Best for: anyone trying to conceive — men or women — who wants to understand how metabolic health, insulin resistance, thyroid function, and GLP-1 medications impact fertility, regardless of whether they have a diagnosed condition like PCOS or diabetes.

👉 Get Personalized Fertility & Intimacy Support — Download WOVA

Podcast Transcript

Gabie Peytchev: Welcome to the WOVA Podcast. Today I have a special guest, Dr. Chhaya Makhija. She's a triple board-certified endocrinologist and lifestyle medicine specialist with nearly 20 years of experience caring for patients. Her passion has always been to help people understand their bodies, prevent disease, and live with vitality and confidence, and that's why she opened her own practice, which is called Univite Endocrine & Diabetes Care.

I'm super excited to talk to you today. I'd love to hear more about your practice, and today I'd like to dig deeper into metabolic health and why it matters for people who are trying to conceive, any gender really. We're going to talk about insulin resistance. We'll talk about thyroid health and GLP-1 medications. Welcome, Dr. Makhija.

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Thank you. Thanks for building such an amazing platform for couples who are expecting to have a larger family or in that journey of coming together as a whole, as a family. So thank you for having me.

Gabie Peytchev: Yeah. Thank you. So let's talk about metabolic health. Why does it matter for fertility?

Why Metabolic Health Matters for Fertility

Gabie Peytchev: Most people usually think when they talk about fertility and when they think about trying for a baby, they think of reproductive hormones, they think of ovarian reserve, they think of sperm health. Why is metabolic health important?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Yeah, absolutely. Great question. One very important, simple way that I would like to answer this question is, what is metabolism, right? It's our engine. Engine meaning, you have your car, you have a machinery, you have an instrument. Everything has a mechanism of how it functions. Same thing with our body. We have trillions and trillions of cells, and these cells are actually one small engine, but trillions of engines that are actually working in harmony, in sync. So that engine in the human body is called metabolism. It needs fuel. It has lots of doors where hormones come in, where your fuel comes in, your glucose comes in, and there is a crosstalk happening throughout the entire body.

So metabolic health is not just one organ system, it's actually your entire whole engine functioning in a way that could be in harmony versus it could shift. And those shifts impact our health, can cause symptoms. And if those shifts are happening in younger individuals or in that reproductive phase for both men and women, can impact fertility and be a challenge even for fertility specialists to optimize it.

So yes, a very important aspect of health.

Chronic Conditions & Metabolic Health

Gabie Peytchev: What chronic conditions are considered part of the metabolic picture?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Sure. So I'll break it down, because for endocrinology, metabolism or the engine that we talked about is in parallel with hormones, because hormones dictate a lot as to how our engine runs. The most important one that I constantly emphasize is insulin, cortisol, and thyroid because none of these hormones that we can sustain our lives without. We can still sustain our lives without estrogen, still sustain our lives without testosterone in men, but we just cannot live without these three hormones. So hormones and the metabolism, our engine, is working in parallel to support each other.

Chronic diseases, meaning it's not a one-week, two-week infection or inflammation that can be resolved. The changes or the negative aspects that are impacting that metabolic or hormonal harmony is going on for a few years, or it could be a few decades. For example, in patients who have type 2 diabetes, when they're diagnosed on blood work, we know that this problem has been going on for the last five years in the pancreas, meaning it could be insulin resistance or it could be prediabetes that they've been living with, and now it manifests as type 2 diabetes five years later. And by the time they're diagnosed, we also know that 50% of your beta cell reserve, meaning the cells which actually produce insulin in the pancreas, they've almost been exhausted, and that's when we have the diagnosis.

So these are chronic diseases where the sooner you take action, the better you have in terms of not being on medications, the better your outcomes, not having complications. And since we are talking about fertility here, the higher chance of females conceiving if their diabetes is either in control or it's been reversed. They were treated sooner when insulin resistance was discovered, which is technically pre-prediabetes stage. And that's why we focus on prevention and these conditions, to prevent chronic diseases which could be type 2 diabetes, for example.

Symptoms of Insulin Resistance to Watch For

Gabie Peytchev: I would assume that a lot of people are, if not diagnosed, and how can you capture what symptoms should you be looking for? And again, this is not just addressed to women trying to conceive, but really anyone who's trying to conceive. What symptoms should you be looking out for to know that, okay, maybe there's an issue here, maybe I have pre-diabetes, maybe I need to take some preventative action?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So just based on since we're in the US, based on American Diabetes Association guidelines, if you have risk factors, meaning anything related to ethnicity — so South Asians, African Americans, Hispanics, Mediterraneans, higher ethnicity — you want to get your A1C or your oral glucose tolerance test, or in some cases, two to three fasting glucose numbers done sooner than age 35. If you don't have risk factors at all, then from 35 onwards annually, these should be tested.

Your question was geared towards more symptoms. And knowing that your audience is interested in fertility, both men and women can have insulin resistance even if their blood sugars are normal, their diabetes testing is normal, their A1C is normal. For us as physicians, if there is darkening of the skin, it could be even the anterior neck, or the posterior neck, meaning the back of your neck, underneath the breast, under arms for both men and women. Where there's a darkening of the skin, it's called acanthosis nigricans. Skin tags, again, seen in men and women more on the neck. Those could be signs of insulin resistance.

And then in terms of for females, if there's been difficulty in conceiving, and you're having regular menstrual cycles or you're tracking your ovulation, but there is inconsistency in ovulation. Because these may not be like symptoms. You're not feeling anything, but now you have tools to figure out that, oh, I'm having regular menstrual cycles doesn't mean that I'm ovulating consistently. All signs raise a red flag for us to look for insulin resistance.

In men, something similar, they might just have a weight gain. Insulin resistance by itself doesn't cause weight gain, but that weight gain led to insulin resistance. It's both back and forth. Some of these individuals may have afternoon crashes if they're eating very high carb meals, simple carb meals. They may feel that they have fatigue or lethargy after they eat such foods. These are just signals to test for insulin resistance. It doesn't mean that every individual having these symptoms has insulin resistance, because many other conditions can also mimic in the same manner in terms of symptoms.

The other thing is there could be a male infertility factor which could be related to insulin resistance. And that is because insulin resistance is one of the root causes even for fatty liver disease, cardiovascular disease, other than type 2 diabetes. So the vascularity, meaning the blood flow, is impacted in men. One of the common causes for erectile dysfunction is actually the testicular blood flow and not the testosterone, right?

So insulin resistance is playing a role in all these root causes. So you may have a delayed symptom, you may have an early symptom, and that's why that becomes one of the things for us to test in both men and women when we are looking at these symptoms, signs, physical examination.

How to Test for Insulin Resistance

Gabie Peytchev: What tests, you mentioned a few, but if we had to write down the tests that you need to be looking at, what are they? And then you also said there's... You could be within the normal range, but you still might have insulin resistance.

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So that was about glucose and A1C. So, when you need to get tested for or screened for prediabetes, diabetes, then the recommendations are either you get a hemoglobin A1C, or you get an oral glucose tolerance test, which you have to go to the lab, drink Glucola or 75 grams of sugar, and they'll check your levels before drinking it, fasting, and then one hour, two hours after. If you fall into a good range, meaning you don't have prediabetes or type 2 diabetes — despite having these tests being normal, which are basic screening tests for prediabetes and type 2 diabetes, we can still have insulin resistance.

And that's why in patients who we are suspicious that they could have insulin resistance based on the clinical features that I talked about, or you're trying to conceive and dealing with weight problems or the symptoms that we just talked about, then we look at or test for glucose level simultaneously with an insulin level and then calculate something called HOMA-IR, which is a homeostatic model. You can just search for the calculation. If those are elevated, for me, the threshold is say greater than two, then it is termed that that is mild insulin resistance. Numbers are higher, it is significant insulin resistance.

Now, that's just a tool. It is not 100% accurate test to diagnose insulin resistance because many of us who still have acanthosis, still have insulin resistance, can have normal levels for the HOMA-IR. But it's a tool or a test that can be utilized while we are evaluating patients when their A1C, when their oral glucose tolerance test is normal, but we are still suspecting insulin resistance.

Insulin Resistance Affects Everyone Trying to Conceive

Gabie Peytchev: So it sounds like basically metabolic health matters for everyone who's trying to conceive, not just for people with PCOS or maybe with higher body weight or who are pre-diabetic or diabetic.

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: You got it. Yes. Yeah. There's a whole big population of South Asian, especially where you reside in Northern California, where there are South Asians, so Indians, Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, Sri Lankans, you know, Nepal. I think Bhutan is included or not, but you know, the entire South Asian population, they're leaner, BMI, but they have the maximum amount of insulin resistance.

And that's why despite being leaner, that lower BMI, they tend to have the higher risk of infertility or insulin resistance causing pre-diabetes, type 2 diabetes in the latter part of their age group. Yes. So you're right. Even if you feel like you're at a good weight, you could still have insulin resistance.

Why Certain Ethnicities Are More Predisposed

Gabie Peytchev: Why are certain ethnicities more predisposed? Is that due to genetics?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Oh, I wish I had an easy answer for this because we still don't know in science. It's still a mystery. But a few things are, yes, it's genetics on how the ancestors or the older generation, what they were exposed to in terms of flood, famine, and the types of foods. And they had a tendency to store more food because there was a lack or unavailability of these foods. So the body tends to work in a reverse manner where it is trying to store food, especially in the liver. And that leads to adiposity in the liver or, you know, that specific group of population is also at a higher risk of fatty liver disease despite not eating much of the fats. So that storage is causing liver disease, is causing insulin resistance. And I'm not going into the biochemistry because of how your audience is, but just sharing that the famine and flood was one of the aspects.

Fast-forward, that's not as true as it was in our older generations, like say if we were talking about our parents or our grandparents. The ones who are in their 40s, 50s or the ones who are in their 20s, 30s, we are not exposed to any form of famine or flood type of a situation. But here it's the exposure to the processed foods, and the types of foods that we are getting exposed to, even though we have patients who are vegans and vegetarians.

Oh my gosh, the utter amount of processed foods and chemicals or the endocrine disruptors that we are surrounded by, that is also contributing to these abnormalities in terms of in regards to insulin resistance. So the South Asian population, they have some genes, right? That they've been exposed to from their grandparents, from their ancestors. Then they're exposed to the environment, which is now currently existing, which is also another trigger to it. The third trigger to it is the way we live now is more sedentary. No matter what, you go to the gym, you exercise, it's just one hour. The next eight to 10 hours you're just sitting and working. So that itself is the third hit. The fourth hit is the sleep. Poor sleep I'm talking about, is very notoriously negatively impacting insulin resistance or insulin sensitivity, so that part is also affected in the 21st era or 21st generation.

So where we started with, that could not have been true anymore, the famine and the flood situation where we were not getting enough access to food. But we've had more triggers over the years to lead to still higher incidence of obesity, type 2 diabetes, fatty liver disease in this population.

Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals & How to Reduce Them

Gabie Peytchev: I'm so glad that you're bringing these points — lifestyle, nutrition, environmental health. They matter so much. People sometimes wonder about how much do they matter. So if we start talking about endocrine disruptors in the environment, for example, where would you start? How would you minimize those endocrine disruptors so you can help your metabolic health?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: That requires intention first, right? Because otherwise we could just go in extremes. One is like, I don't want to change anything. I don't think this is impacting. There are other things that matter for fertility, and I don't care about it. Or the other extreme would be that I'll give up everything that is available in the environment which is processed or is plastic. And then that may add more stressors to you because maybe your expenses are increasing or you're trying to shop for these products which are very, very, very organic or natural. But that's also leading to more stress in terms of how you're approaching that aspect. So I'm not talking about extremes. What we could do is first intentional and being aware.

So as simple as the plastics that we tend to use — where are, you know, top three things or five things that I've been using plastic that I can just get rid of? I'm talking about getting rid of, not just compromising, oh, mornings I can use it and afternoons I can't because I'm busy. So plastic is, you know, anything that you store your foods into, your containers. If you've ever been taking takeouts, which is so common, you know, don't use that takeout food and warm it in whatever that container is. It could be the plastic container, it could be paper, it could be cardboard, right?

You're just eating, absolutely, cardboard food, as simple as that. Or you're eating plastic food. So get rid of those things, which could be very simple. It doesn't cost you anything. It's just that intention which would help you to take action, right? And then if you had to invest, you know, maybe just containers which are microwave safe, or heating your foods on your gas oven in your steel containers, or wherever you cook food, would be much beneficial in terms of a simple change from here to there, and it didn't cost you anything in terms of energy or real dollars.

It's your intention. The second thing is plastic bottles, right? And this could be fine. Like, we would be more intentional at homes that, you know, it's okay, I will use my glass, or I could use my steel container to drink water. And I've become intentional. It's more during travel. It's more during when you're out of your homes. It's more at work. Your plastic forks and spoons, right? Are you educating people around you that, "Hey, can we just have some steel utensils or silverware at work in offices?" And, you know, just take turns in terms of if you don't have a dishwasher, just take turns. Or have your own silverware in your office, as simple as that. I do that personally, and I try to when there are conferences that... Many conferences where it's very much doable. I can completely understand if it's larger conferences or meetings. When we are in offices, like say if I am working in an office or I am going to another office, can I encourage them that, "Hey, why are you buying so many plastic bottles?"

Can we have just a glass container of water and then have some cups so that we could actually save the environment? But also you're saving the other human being from not getting exposed to plastic, from not getting exposed to these endocrine disruptors. So two simple steps. I just talked about the food containers and the plastic ware or the water, because food and water is our daily essential. And if we start with those two changes, we become intentional, and then the third step will get easier. Meaning, you know, what kind of cookware I'm using to cook dishes, and then what kind of products I'm buying, what kind of chemicals I'm using on my body. Then comes those next steps.

But that also will come along when you've fulfilled the first two essentials, that is your food and water.

Gabie Peytchev: These are amazing tips. It would be really helpful if you could explain why — like how, what happens in the body when we're consuming so much plastics and even other endocrine-disrupting chemicals. How is that affecting our metabolic health, our endocrine systems, immune systems? What happens?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So, you know, this is also very complex. It's not as simple as when you talk to a fertility specialist or a reproductive endocrinologist — they will explain the real data of what is happening with these BPAs or the plastics with endocrine disruption. In the realm of metabolic health, right? Because we were talking about diabetes or obesity or even thyroid, because that's an essential one. And how our body composition might get also affected, meaning how we distribute weight. So I'll just simplify the explanation also, is that our hormones are these very minute chemicals, or you can call them as messengers, right?

They cannot be visualized. They can only be tested in the blood. And, you know, though, when you're testing in the blood, these are — like, just for example, glucose is checked as milligram per deciliter. So milligram, you know, the molecule is larger. Hormones could be microinternational units, could be nano, micrograms or nanomilligrams, right? So they're really in that tiny, tiny amounts, but they have very large impact. And they're being produced by most of the endocrine glands which are really tiny. Except for, you know, the pancreas could be large, but pancreas is contributing to both hormone and the gut health or the enzymes for digestion. So for example, our pituitary gland is just sitting underneath the base of the brain, so just behind your two eyebrows where they meet, the bridge of the nose. It's a pea-sized gland. It produces the most important hormonal signals which is going to your adrenal gland so that for the cortisol, it's ACTH. It's going to your thyroid, it produces TSH. It produces prolactin, which is an essential one to know when someone's conceiving or we are testing that if someone's not ovulating. Your growth hormone, right? So essential one, as we require growth hormone for our growth. And then it's also regulating our salt and water balance.

So there's something called as vasopressin or antidiuretic hormone and oxytocin. Oxytocin is that love hormone. It's that bonding hormone that we all need. You give a hug to someone, you're raising your oxytocin. So these are the hormones. I just started with the list of hormones. There are numerous others.

But just to give you a context of these are so tiny micro, micro molecules. And now when we are getting exposed to plastics or we are getting exposed to these cardboard foods, right? Basically the breakage of these plastics or compounds, they are messing with the cross-signaling or the hormonal function. Now, we don't have a study or a randomized control trial that, you know, 100 females or 100 men had plastic-contained water for the last 10 years, and it directly showed that it affected their pituitary hormone signals. We don't have those randomized control trials, and we shouldn't be doing it just for ethical purposes because you know that it's going to cause a negative impact. How much of a negative impact is what's not known. The more we get exposed to it, the more disruption of these signals. For females, it is more relevant to the FSH, LH, and estrogen, progesterone signaling. It is also impacting our inflammation. We tend to have a higher risk of autoimmune conditions, and we have enough data to show that there is a correlation between these endocrine disruptors and the autoimmunity that is more prevalent and higher incidence now in the last two or three decades. Thyroid, most common conditions are autoimmune governed. So that leads to disruption there.

So the point is that we have enough data that we got exposed to chemicals, plastics, and they caused a disruption in signaling. It's not that they're causing deficiencies, they're not the sole factor. And there are other triggers, just like we talked about South Asians, right? They had the triggers from the ancestors, but now they're exposed to the others. So endocrine disruptors, getting exposed to these chemicals is one trigger, and no doubt in this 21st era, we are getting exposed to the other triggers which lead to disease as a whole. I hope that simplifies it rather than me talking about each chemical and each compound and each study.

Gabie Peytchev: Yeah, that's perfect. I think it's very helpful just to get an idea of how all of these endocrine-disrupting chemicals in our environment have so much effect on our overall body, on all of these different hormones that are so important when you're trying to conceive. So it's good to have the understanding behind before you can take action.

Lifestyle Medicine: Nutrition, Movement & Sleep

Gabie Peytchev: And then you also mentioned movement and sleep quality and nutrition. In your practice, since you are also certified in lifestyle medicine, can we talk about these as well? What tips do you provide to your patients?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Sure. You know, I'm pretty sure you've had this discussion with your other clinicians and physicians, and it's definitely going to overlap because lifestyle medicine is boring. Meaning repeat the same thing, and you'll feel the results. It's simple. The reason I say boring is because the more repetition happens with it, meaning there's more consistency, the better results we see. And when I say we, meaning not as clinicians that we see, even the patients or even people will witness it, right? So as simple as having plant-forward meals, and I'm not talking about being a vegetarian or a vegan. Plant-forward meals is, can I incorporate plant foods in my daily meals?

And it doesn't have to be plant foods which are just potatoes or broccoli, that's about it. There is diversity and again, being very intentional — can I get exposed to these? Can I try these out rather than just saying that, "Blah, I don't like the taste, and I'll just stick to the American meal," which is a steak, potatoes, and broccoli by itself.

I'm not saying that's bad by any means, but can I expose myself to a variety of plant foods?

Gabie Peytchev: I just wanted to quickly mention I've been watching your Instagram stories. You seem to be a really good chef too, 'cause I see you are incorporating many...

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Yeah, I learned cooking when I was in residency, so probably in my early 30s, because, you know, you get frustrated with... And I miss home-cooked meals like what mom used to make, and that's how I was like, "Okay, let's experiment, experiment, experiment," and then, you know, how can I add diversity?

So thank you. But no, no, no close to chef. I don't have my own recipes. I just talk to the vegetables and figure out what to cook with spices. But the point is like, you know, being open-minded in terms of, okay, let me experiment this, rather than thinking that I have to follow a very difficult recipe and spend two hours in cooking. The reason I said first one is plant-forward meals is because of anti-inflammatory effects of it. You know, the antioxidants that basically fight your free radicals. So your endocrine disruptors are leading to formation of free radicals. Your plant foods can fight it. Of course, you have to take the triggers away too, but that's the anti-inflammatory effect or antioxidant effect that I'm talking about. Your chia seeds, your flax seeds, your nuts and seeds are all in the plant-based world. And then beans and lentils are phenomenal. You know, just try to mix and match. You can cook your meats in beans and lentils and make it yummy as well. So that's one bridge to cross, which is not a difficult one.

And simultaneously comes your movement, and in movement we have both. One is breathwork, and the second one is a physical movement, meaning exercise, right? So again, I'm pretty sure you've had clinicians talk about strength training, about working on the muscles, about impact exercises, some form of weight bearing or walking and stretching because, you know, you're helping your bone health, your muscle health at the same time. But any form of walking is great for our mental health. I had interviewed on my podcast a psychiatrist, and he mentioned a couple of studies which showed that for mild to moderate depression, daily walking outdoors is equal to antidepressants in terms of the effect of treating mild and moderate depression, right?

So very, very important when a couple is going through planning for conception. Breathing is also a part of movement, because we've forgotten how to breathe. We don't remember, nor are we intentional, and we don't even realize that we are breathing, okay? Just the fact that while you're listening to this podcast with Gabby, and you just take a couple of breaths and just be aware of it is a great way of training yourself in the world of mindfulness, is a great way of training yourself and to be in a meditative state. You didn't do anything.

So that is what is incorporated when I'm having these patient discussions. The third one is, you know, the sleep and stress. But whatever we talked about as nutrition and movement also helps us with the sleep and stress. The more we are physically at rest, meaning aware about our breathing, now we can train our thoughts. We cannot train our thoughts when we are flustered, when we are angry, when we are rushing, when we are trying to multitask. It doesn't happen. So just giving yourself those few moments will actually help us to now internally reflect and figure out, okay, where can my stress response be, and how can I do the good self-talk?

The oxytocin hormone that we talked about, so hugging, right? If you don't like hugs, that's okay. You can send virtual hugs. But connecting to humans beyond screens is very important. Yes, you could talk to your parents. You could talk to your buddies. You could talk to your neighbors. Text them. You could be in touch on social media and be the best buddies on the internet or the social media world. But connecting one-on-one with each other. It doesn't have to be your family or friends. It could just be a stranger while you're walking on the street, you know. How often are you actually smiling? How often are you thanking someone, or how often are you even having your sight outside at the world rather than on your phone or on your watch or on the screen. So being observant itself is also a good way to connect because when you observe, you will know that you are very much available to serve and you are able to give. And that part brings about the most fulfillment and gratitude within yourself. Because we all have good attributes which we can give away, and we'll still become fuller and fuller. So once that part is also recognized and we are actually practicing it in our daily lives, that's a big part of improving our metabolic health, our mental health, our physical health, our psychological well-being, and how the hormones talk to each other, including our gut health.

What Is Insulin Resistance?

Gabie Peytchev: Thank you. We've been talking for the last 30 minutes about insulin resistance, but we didn't really define it. What is insulin resistance?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Sure. So the simplified explanation would be — we talked about those trillions of cells, but the cells in the muscle, in the liver, in our fat, adipose tissue, that's the fat cells, they are resistant to insulin, meaning the insulin is just hovering around outside the doors of these cells, but these cells are saying, "You can't come in." Now, why is it important for that insulin to get inside is because unless insulin doesn't get into the cells, your cells cannot use glucose as effectively or as efficiently as a fuel. Now, if it's not able to use it as a fuel and all this extra glucose is just circulating in the blood, and your pancreas is detecting it that, "Oh my gosh, there is still a lot of glucose circulating in the blood," so pancreas will release even more insulin.

Like, let me just bombard these cells with more insulin outside the door and now, you know, 10 insulin molecules will push through and enter inside the cell, and now the cell will take away the glucose. So it is hyperinsulinemia, meaning that same person has to produce more insulin to make sure that glucose enters into the cell, and it prevents that excess glucose to be circulating in the blood. So that is why I explained that these patients can have insulin resistance — like all this phenomena is going on, but the body is still successful to maintain normal glucose, and they don't have prediabetes or diabetes. But the body is really working hard to maintain normal blood sugars, and when it gets exhausted, meaning when pancreas gets exhausted, that's when we end up having prediabetes and type 2 diabetes because no more there is adequate insulin to push through and maintain normal glucose level.

The main reason that we know it happens — there are multiple reasons for insulin resistance, like the background changes. But one of the very important things is that we tend to store fat. I'm not talking about just the fat that we eat, but the molecules inside the cell, they hold on to these fat molecules, and they make the door, the insulin door, very sticky, so they don't let insulin enter inside. Best way to improve insulin resistance or to decrease insulin resistance is exercise, the best way. So contracting your muscles because muscle cells are the only cells which can take glucose inside without much of a need of insulin molecule. So that is why there are simple remedies to improve insulin resistance at a certain stage, which is your exercise, your walking, muscle contraction, making them move, post-meal walks.

How Insulin Resistance Affects Ovulation

Gabie Peytchev: Amazing. Thank you. Very helpful. We talked about at some point earlier also ovulation, that insulin resistance could affect ovulation. You could have regular periods, but you might not be ovulating. And also you could have PCOS, but maybe not, and you could still have issues with ovulation. How is insulin resistance affecting ovulation?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Sure. Gonna be a full podcast, by the way. So because hormones are not something that this happened and this led to what happened, right? There was a dysfunction here, and this is what the outcome was. There is a lot of crosstalk happening, and that's why endocrinology becomes a specialty because a crosstalk is complex. It's not complicated, it's complex, like intertwined.

We learned about insulin resistance, and also understanding that when someone has insulin resistance, so in females, that same hyperinsulinemia or extra insulin getting circulated can tell the ovaries. When it says tell the ovaries, meaning it has receptors, so it stimulates more androgen production, meaning male hormone production, meaning testosterone. In general, as females, our ovaries do produce testosterone, but usually the estrogen ratio is higher as compared to testosterone. But when there is insulin resistance, that extra insulin is telling the ovaries produce more androgen. So there is more androgen synthesis, more DHEA testosterone production happening, and that can impair the ovulation or that can present as something called as hirsutism or missed, irregularities in the menstrual cycles, and that leads to disruptions in how the woman is ovulating or the ovulatory cycles can be inconsistent.

So that's just one pathway. But there are multiple others which tend to dysregulate the signals from the pituitary, that is LH, FSH, and that's the second pathway which is more hormonal governed and not insulin resistance governed in PCOS. And there are multiple other things happening in the liver, in terms of our body composition. Some of these women will have more follicles in the ovary, and that is because of the LH, FSH, like immature follicles. There are multiple hits that are happening at the same time, and each person or each female with insulin resistance or PCOS — two different scenarios — can have variations in the spectrum. Every individual can present in a different manner depending on what path is more prominent or what pathway has become more prominent in terms of affecting their ovulation negatively.

Addressing Insulin Resistance Before Fertility Treatment

Gabie Peytchev: Now, if someone has insulin resistance or prediabetes, should they address it before pursuing fertility treatment, or can things be managed in parallel with their fertility team?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So that also depends on what fertility plan is happening, right? So say if they were planning for natural conception versus were they planning to have some assisted form of fertility planning. If they have insulin resistance, once — if they've started and blood sugars are normal, A1c is normal, then you can just work on lifestyle interventions.

Weight is normal. They don't have any other risk factors that could impact the assisted fertility procedures negatively, then they should be good to going with working with their fertility teams. What matters is if they have prediabetes or type 2 diabetes. Most of the fertility specialists I work with, they would want the A1c to be less than 6% or, you know, as normal as it could get, in individuals with prediabetes, with diabetes, type 2 diabetes, existing one or type 1 diabetes.

They would prefer that A1c is less than 6.5 or less than 6, so that their risk of complications during pregnancy are lower, if they're going to the assisted fertility procedures or even natural conception. So it all depends. Some of these patients may have other metabolic conditions which usually coincide. So they may have high triglycerides, they may have fatty liver disease, or it may just be the weight changes or weight BMI or obesity. So in those individuals, if they can buy two to three months before they plan the fertility procedures, I think that would be more ideal because you end up gaining more weight during pregnancy, you end up having more hormonal fluctuations with assisted techniques because they're getting hormonal injections. And the third is, they can have higher triglycerides during pregnancy because estrogen stimulates the production of triglycerides. That can worsen, so ideal to control it before conceiving.

Insulin Resistance & Sperm Health

Gabie Peytchev: Does insulin resistance also impact sperm health?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So high blood sugars or uncontrolled high blood sugars, absolutely. But say if someone's blood sugars or a male's blood sugars are very well controlled, and they have insulin resistance either on physical findings or the lab test, but their metabolic aspect, other metabolic aspect, meaning the liver is good, the blood sugars are excellent in terms of what the control is, then it shouldn't directly impact or be the sole source of reduced sperm count because you've tried to control it with lifestyle interventions or medications which don't affect the sperm count.

GLP-1 Medications Explained

Gabie Peytchev: Now you mentioned medications. Let's move to GLP-1 medications. In what situations, first of all, is it for everyone, and in what situations would you recommend them?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So GLP-1 medications have specific indications, so definitely it's not the one that's going in water, so not for everyone. And especially not yet approved for a woman who is already pregnant or even in her postpartum phase while she's nursing. So, are medications which have been FDA approved for more than 20 years.

Successfully, right? Like, no problems, natural delivery and, you know, what you would envision that, okay, I don't have to see so many doctors while I'm pregnant.

That's what happened to her. Now she needed insulin during pregnancy because she had existing type 2 diabetes. The point is that it does change the internal milieu, and there are lots of patients with these conditions, women, who could actually benefit. Because sometimes if you tell them that, "Oh, work on lifestyle," and you tell them, "Let's plan for it," you know, a year passes, two years pass, three years pass, and we don't realize that it's the ovarian age also that we are looking at. So how do we help them sooner, and in a safe manner, and actually optimizing their health but also reducing their complications? So definitely in these individuals, it can absolutely help.

Gabie Peytchev: Thank you for sharing the success story. I love it.

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Yeah.

Thyroid Health & Fertility

Gabie Peytchev: Also talk about thyroid health and finalize the episode, 'cause we promised our audience, and I'm sure there's a lot of questions around thyroid health. Can we talk about the symptoms, the testing?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Sure. So every woman usually should get a thyroid test done during their annual screening, and that's usually thyroid-stimulating hormone, TSH. But I highly recommend to get a total T4 or a free T4. Our guidelines do suggest that if TSH is abnormal, then get the T4. Practical problem is that a patient cannot just go to the lab twice.

Why don't you just get it at the same time, you know, help them save another needle stick. So T4 is your thyroid hormone. TSH is a pituitary signal. And in regards to your audience, women conceiving, there are two different conditions, hypo and hyperthyroidism, which is overactive or underactive. So there are different ways of treatment because there are two different extreme conditions. But in general, I think the more common one that we have a lot of, or fears, is related to hypothyroidism, Hashimoto's, antibodies. So thyroid hormone, TSH, T4 — you don't need to know about your hormone status based on antibodies.

Antibodies are for different reasons. Antibodies are just to see, do you have autoimmunity or not. It doesn't test your hormone level. You've gotten TSH, T4, and if you're planning to conceive, if your TSH levels are higher, usually, you know, greater than 3, 4, 5, and your fertility specialist, your gynecologist, or your clinician, your endocrinologist is getting TPO antibodies — TPO antibodies in a woman with a high TSH needs to be treated. And that is because we've seen that the mild elevations of the thyroid-stimulating hormone or TSH with that lingering TPO antibodies can increase the rate of miscarriages, and that's why we are more preemptive and proactive in treating them before they plan to conceive or to optimize their chance of conception. So that's the underactive or hypothyroidism or something called a subclinical, meaning you're not overtly hypothyroid, but we are treating you because you have the presence of antibodies and you're planning to conceive.

Gabie Peytchev: You mentioned there's lots of common myths and it would be nice to debunk a few.

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Yeah, one is Hashimoto's, right? So Hashimoto's is the Japanese scientist who discovered these antibodies. So that's why I mentioned that TPO antibodies do not diagnose hypo or hyperthyroidism, meaning your hormone levels are based on TSH and T4, not based on TPO antibodies.

That's one important thing. And the second one is, do you need to be treated with thyroid hormone? That's where I explain that a woman in the reproductive age group or planning to conceive, and if her TSH is slightly higher, that is, you know, greater than 3, 4, 5, and they have presence of TPO antibodies, it's definitely a discussion to consider treatment in those scenarios to reduce the rate of miscarriages. Again, that becomes more of a patient-physician shared decision-making. The other one is, taking too many iodine supplements will help your thyroid. So that's again a word of caution here that if you're born in an iodine sufficient area, that is, your soil has adequate iodine.

If you're living in United States, you do. There are just certain geographic areas which are where the soil is deficient in iodine. So most of us are not the ones probably who are listening to this podcast. Or you can check your geographic area. Most of us are exposed to iodized salt.

If you're not using it at home, you're definitely eating outside. Most of the times it's iodized salt. So we don't need extra iodine supplementation, except for when someone's planning for conception or when they're pregnant. And that's why prenatal vitamins have around 150 micrograms of iodine, which is helpful for their requirements. But you don't have to bulk up on iodine by just taking an extra iodine supplement or just taking lots of daily seaweed, because that can negatively impact your thyroid or cause thyroiditis, inflammation of your thyroid. So that's third myth, which is very common, that, "Oh, let me just take extra iodine supplements and fix my thyroid." Quite unsafe in terms of a supplement. What else would you like me to share?

Insulin Resistance & Thyroid Health Connection

Gabie Peytchev: Oh, this is super helpful. Last question, what's the connection between insulin resistance and thyroid health?

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: So there are multiple ways that I could connect. I'm thinking about how your audience would benefit. If someone has hypothyroidism, meaning underactive thyroid, and it's not being treated, that leads to more weight gain, it could lead to water retention, it could lead to lethargy, it could lead to like this swelling around your eyelids, because there is less thyroid hormone in your system and it's not being treated. When this is happening, the metabolic changes can also happen where the blood sugars start rising, there is more insulin resistance because there is more fat deposition because of the weight gain. There is a rise in blood sugars, so dyslipidemia or high LDL. So treat the thyroid first or the hypothyroid condition, and then the other metabolic aspects, once they improve, come back to your baseline, then those could be addressed. So under treatment of hypothyroidism can cause these metabolic changes, and one of them would be the insulin resistance.

Wrap-Up & Thank You

Gabie Peytchev: Amazing. And don't forget about these endocrine-disrupting chemicals, reducing them in the environment, all the different lifestyle strategies we discussed, they all help. But like you mentioned, sometimes you need actual treatment and medication. So depending on the situation, talk to your doctor.

Thank you so much for this valuable information. I really appreciate you coming to the podcast and sharing your knowledge and wisdom with us. Thank you.

Dr. Chhaya Makhija: Absolutely. Thanks for having me, Gabby.

🌿 Connect with WOVA:

Instagram: @wovahealth

Join WOVA: Start Here

Take the Fertility Quiz:

Gabie’s Story: About

‍ ‍

🎙️ Subscribe & Share
If you found this episode helpful, subscribe on your favorite channel, leave a review, or share it with someone on their TTC journey. Your support helps others find this space.

Next
Next

🎧 Episode 19: Decoding Your Menstrual Cycle: What Your Period, Cervical Mucus & Fertility Signs Reveal About Your Health | Dr. Colleen Holland